Changing tracks: inside IR35, outside IR35 and everything in between
Contracting used to be relatively simple: agree a day rate, do the work, invoice and move on. IR35 changed that, but the bigger lesson for me has been learning to think like a business rather than somebody waiting for the next contract.
When I first started contracting, IR35 was already there. It had existed since 2000. But I honestly don’t remember it being much of a conversation.
You got a contract, agreed a day rate, went in and did the work, submitted your timesheet, sent an invoice and got paid through your company.
That was basically it.
In practice, outside IR35 always felt like the starting point.
You were running a business. You had your own company, your own accountant, your own equipment, your own insurance and your own responsibilities. You sorted your own tax out. If you weren’t working, nobody paid you. If you went on holiday, nobody paid you. If the contract ended on Friday, you could be earning absolutely nothing on Monday.
That was the deal.
And for years, it worked.
I understood why IR35 existed
I’ve never really disagreed with the basic principle behind IR35.
There were people who had been sitting inside organisations for years and years, sometimes doing effectively the same job as permanent employees. Nine years. Twelve years. Whatever.
At some point, if you’re doing exactly the same role, working in exactly the same way and effectively becoming part of the furniture, I can understand why somebody starts asking whether you’re genuinely running an independent business.
There were always ridiculous stories around it too.
People apparently working remotely from Spain, sitting by a swimming pool while technically contracting into some huge organisation back in the UK. Whether every one of those stories was actually true is another matter, but they became part of the mythology around contracting.
I could understand why the government wanted to deal with disguised employment.
What I never understood was why the solution needed to make genuine contracting so complicated.
If I get somebody in to paint my house, replace my windows or do some building work, I’m not employing them.
They come in, do a job, invoice me and leave.
They might be there for two days. They might be there for three months.
They’re still running their own business.
For some reason, once you put a laptop in front of somebody rather than a paintbrush, we managed to make the whole thing enormously complicated.
My business looked like a business
This was one of the frustrating things for me personally.
I wasn’t pretending to run a company.
I was running one.
My wife works through the business as well and does completely different work to me, mainly around HR consultancy. She has her clients. I have mine. There can be several companies being invoiced at the same time.
Even if I’d been with one client for twelve months, the invoices going to them wouldn’t necessarily be sequential because other invoices were being raised in between.
I’ve worked remotely for years. Long before COVID made remote working normal, I had contracts where I might only go into an office for important meetings.
I’ve bought and used my own equipment. I’ve managed my own workload. I’ve worked with different clients.
That’s what running a small business looks like.
It isn’t always clean and convenient. That’s partly the point.
Government systems generally seem to work best when everybody fits neatly into the same box.
Employee. Salary. PAYE. Pension. Holiday allowance.
Nice and easy to categorise.
The moment you don’t quite fit into one of those boxes, everything becomes more difficult.
And contractors don’t fit particularly neatly into them.
Then everything changed
The really significant change wasn’t the invention of IR35 itself.
It was moving responsibility for deciding somebody’s status away from the contractor and towards the organisation hiring them.
That happened in the public sector first in 2017. It was then supposed to reach medium and large private-sector organisations in April 2020. COVID delayed it for a year, so the change eventually came into force in April 2021.
But the disruption had started before then.
Companies were preparing. Recruiters were trying to understand what clients were going to do. Contractors were trying to understand what would happen to existing engagements.
Some organisations simply decided they didn’t want the risk.
Suddenly a relatively straightforward conversation about a project, a day rate and whether you were the right person for the work had another enormous layer attached to it.
Inside or outside IR35?
Who has made the determination?
Will the client allow outside-IR35 contractors?
Does the recruiter understand it?
Does the client understand it?
Has somebody completed CEST?
Has somebody simply decided all contractors are inside because that’s easier?
It created this strange loop where everybody was asking everybody else what the answer was.
Recruiters were stuck in the middle. Clients didn’t necessarily understand the legislation. Contractors were trying to explain how their own businesses operated.
The irony was that the people who seemed to understand the implications best were often the contractors themselves, because it directly affected whether we could actually take the work.
CEST didn’t exactly make things easier
Then there was HMRC’s Check Employment Status for Tax tool, or CEST.
I never had much faith in it.
Employment status is incredibly dependent on the reality of a working relationship. Control matters. Substitution matters. Mutuality of obligation matters. Working practices matter.
The contract matters, but what actually happens day to day matters as well.
Trying to reduce all of that to a decision tree on a government website always seemed optimistic.
And it wasn’t just contractors criticising it. Parliamentary scrutiny raised serious concerns about whether CEST properly reflected employment-status case law, particularly around mutuality of obligation.
Yet businesses were being asked to make fairly significant decisions using it.
That was the strange thing about the whole period.
Everyone wanted certainty, but the system seemed to create more uncertainty.
It hit me harder than I expected
I don’t think I’ve ever really written about this bit.
When everything started changing around 2020 and 2021, it really affected me.
I remember being almost in tears at one point.
It sounds dramatic written down now, but the contracting market I’d built my career around suddenly looked completely different. Something that had worked for years seemed to change almost overnight.
And when you’ve structured your finances around running a limited company, moving onto an inside-IR35 engagement isn’t simply the same thing with a bit more tax taken off.
The whole financial structure is different.
Your company still exists. It still has costs. You may still have accountancy, equipment, software, insurance and all the other expenses involved in running it.
But the income from that particular engagement is being treated very differently.
For people who had built genuine businesses around contracting, it wasn’t a small administrative change.
It changed the economics.
For about five minutes, it looked like it might disappear
One of my strongest memories of the whole saga is the brief moment when it looked as though the reforms might actually be reversed.
In September 2022, Liz Truss’s government announced that the 2017 and 2021 off-payroll reforms would be repealed. Contractors would once again become responsible for determining their own status.
For a moment there was this collective feeling of: finally.
Then the government imploded, Jeremy Hunt became Chancellor and in October the repeal was cancelled.
IR35 was staying.
It was almost comical.
After everything the contracting market had been through, we got a few weeks of thinking the old system might return before the door slammed shut again.
At that point there wasn’t much else to do except adapt.
I was never going permanent
One thing I did know was that I wasn’t suddenly going to become a permanent employee because the rules had changed.
I’ve never particularly wanted to be employed.
That isn’t because I can’t work in teams. I’ve worked in tiny teams and enormous organisations. I’ve been managed and I’ve managed other people.
I just know how I work.
I manage myself better than anybody else could manage me.
Nobody is going to put more pressure on me to get something finished than I put on myself. If I’ve said something will be done, I’ll get it done.
That’s how I’ve always worked.
The idea that the answer to IR35 was therefore to find a permanent job never made much sense to me.
The answer was to work out how the business adapted.
Then came the fixed-term contract
More recently I’ve noticed another change.
The fixed-term contract.
You’ll see a role advertised for twelve months on a salary and described as a contract.
To me, that’s an employment contract.
That’s not what I’ve traditionally understood contracting to be.
If you’re paid a salary, expected to work as an employee, given the same working pattern as an employee and perhaps expected in the office several days a week for the next year, we’ve started stretching the definition of “contractor” beyond recognition.
There’s absolutely nothing wrong with somebody wanting that arrangement.
I just think we should call it what it is.
Remote work has gone backwards too
The other thing I find strange is how much noise there is around remote and hybrid working now.
Product design has worked remotely for years.
It wasn’t some great experiment invented during COVID.
I’ve spent a lot of my career working towards sprints, milestones and designated pieces of delivery. Everyone knows what’s supposed to be delivered. You do the work. You have the meetings you need to have. You get the sprint completed.
Where everybody happens to be sitting has often been largely irrelevant.
COVID proved on a massive scale that organisations could function that way.
Then the pendulum started swinging back towards hybrid and office attendance.
I have my own suspicion about some of that.
COVID also demonstrated what happens to places like central London when huge numbers of office workers stop travelling in. Trains are quieter. Coffee shops are quieter. Restaurants are quieter. Shops lose passing trade. Commercial property suddenly looks rather expensive.
There’s an entire economy built around people travelling into cities and spending money while they’re there.
I can’t prove that’s the reason behind every return-to-office policy, obviously. I’m sure organisations have all sorts of reasons for wanting people together.
But I do think there’s a much bigger economic system around office working than simply whether your team collaborates better on a Tuesday when everybody is in the same building.
Whatever the reason, from a contractor’s point of view it feels like another thing that’s become more complicated than it used to be.
SOWs might actually be where this goes next
What I find more interesting is the growth in statement-of-work engagements.
I’ve probably done more SOW-based work in the last couple of years than at any other point in my career.
And actually, I think it makes a lot of sense.
Instead of somebody effectively buying your time indefinitely, you agree the work.
Here’s the problem.
Here’s what we’re delivering.
Here are the milestones.
Here’s roughly how much time it’ll take.
Here’s the cost.
Then you get on with it.
It starts looking much more like a genuine business-to-business relationship.
In many ways, it takes contracting back towards what I always thought contracting should be.
You’re being brought in because something needs doing.
Do it.
Then leave.
Fractional work is part of that too
I think fractional working is another part of where this is heading.
Years ago, you were more likely to join somewhere for three months, six months or a year and work pretty much continuously with that organisation.
Now I see more situations where somebody might need you two days a week, a few days a month or heavily for one phase of a project before dropping down later.
I like that.
It means experienced people can work across several businesses rather than pretending every company needs another full-time person.
And for companies it means they can buy the experience they need without having to hire somebody permanently to fill every possible gap.
Again, that’s what a business relationship looks like to me.
A contract isn’t actually what you need
This is probably the biggest thing I’ve learned from all of it.
When you’re looking for contract work, it’s very easy to convince yourself that what you need is another contract.
You don’t.
You need money.
That sounds incredibly obvious, but I think it’s an important distinction.
A contract is one mechanism for your business to make money.
Freelance work is another.
A statement of work is another.
A fractional engagement is another.
A direct client is another.
A product is another.
A small business website is another.
Consultancy is another.
Building something yourself and selling it is another.
Over the years I’ve tried all sorts. I’ve built my own app. I’ve built businesses. At one point I even set up my own fashion store on Shopify.
Some ideas worked better than others, obviously.
But that’s beside the point.
You try things.
That’s what businesses do.
Once you stop thinking, “I need somebody to give me a contract”, and start thinking, “How can my business make money?”, the whole thing opens up again.
The market hasn’t necessarily got worse
I think contracting has gone on a bit of a diet since the IR35 reforms.
There don’t seem to be as many career contractors around as there once were. Some became permanent. Some stopped contracting. Some moved into different ways of working.
But I’m not sure I would say the market has necessarily got worse.
It’s changed.
Outside IR35 still exists.
Inside IR35 exists.
There are fixed-term employment contracts.
There are SOWs.
There are fractional roles.
There are direct clients.
There are projects.
There are businesses that just need somebody experienced to come in for three weeks, sort something out and disappear again.
That’s probably the bit we need to get better at recognising.
The label matters less than the commercial relationship underneath it.
I’m still running a business
IR35 didn’t stop me contracting.
It certainly made it harder at times.
It made recruitment more complicated. It made clients more cautious. It changed rates, structures and the types of engagements available. And it probably pushed quite a few people out of contracting altogether.
But if anything, it reinforced something I’d probably already known.
I’m not a permanent employee who happens to invoice through a company.
I’m running a business.
Sometimes that business supplies me to a client for a long design contract. Sometimes it’s a short project. Sometimes it’s a statement of work. Sometimes it’s a few days a month. Sometimes I build something myself.
And sometimes I try an idea that goes absolutely nowhere.
That’s the freedom, but it’s also the risk.
Most of the IR35 debate, the tax rules, the determination tools, the hybrid policies and the different contract structures are ultimately noise around something much simpler.
We want to work.
We want to get paid.
And we want to do the best job we possibly can.
I’d quite happily get back to concentrating on that.